Arizona Softball NFCA All-Americans
60 PLAYERS • 114 ALL-AMERICA HONORS
| YEAR | NAME | 1st, 2nd or 3rd TEAM | POSITION |
| 1984 | |||
| Karen Fellenz | 1st Team | Second Base | |
| 1988 | |||
| Teresa Cherry | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| 1990 | |||
| Vivian Holm | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Nicki Dennis | 2nd Team | Third Base | |
| Julie Jones | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| 1991 | |||
| Julie Standering | 1st Team | Shortstop | |
| Julie Jones | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| Debby Day | 3rd Team | Pitcher | |
| 1992 | |||
| Debby Day | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Jody Miller-Pruitt | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Jamie Heggen | 2nd Team | Outfield | |
| Susie Parra | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| Amy Chellevold | 3rd Team | First Base | |
| 1993 | |||
| Jamie Heggen | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Susie Parra | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Amy Chellevold | 2nd Team | First Base | |
| Laura Espinoza | 2nd Team | Shortstop | |
| Jody Miller-Pruitt | 2nd Team | Catcher | |
| 1994 | |||
| Leah Braatz | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Amy Chellevold | 1st Team | First Base | |
| Jenny Dalton | 1st Team | Second Base | |
| Laura Espinoza | 1st Team | Shortstop | |
| Leah O'Brien | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Susie Parra | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| 1995 | |||
| Leah Braatz | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Amy Chellevold | 1st Team | First Base | |
| Jenny Dalton | 1st Team | Second Team | |
| Carrie Dolan | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Laura Espinoza | 1st Team | Shortstop | |
| Leah O'Brien | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| 1996 | |||
| Jenny Dalton | 1st Team | Second Base | |
| Alison McCutcheon | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Leticia Pineda | 1st Team | First Base | |
| Carrie Dolan | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| Krista Gomez | 2nd Team | Third Base | |
| Brandi Shriver | 2nd Team | Outfield | |
| 1997 | |||
| Leah Braatz | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Nancy Evans | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Alison McCutcheon | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Leah O'Brien | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Leticia Pineda | 1st Team | Third Base | |
| 1998 | |||
| Lauren Bauer | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Leah Braatz | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Nancy Evans | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Toni Mascarenas | 1st Team | Third Base | |
| Alison McCutcheon | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Leticia Pineda | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| 1999 | |||
| Lauren Bauer | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| Nicole Giordano | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| Becky Lemke | 3rd Team | Pitcher | |
| 2000 | |||
| Jennie Finch | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Lauren Bauer | 2nd Team | Outfield | |
| Nicole Giordano | 2nd Team | Outfield | |
| Toni Mascarenas | 2nd Team | Third Base | |
| Lindsey Collins | 3rd Team | Catcher | |
| 2001 | |||
| Lauren Bauer | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Jennie Finch | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Leneah Manuma | 1st Team | First Base | |
| Toni Mascarenas | 1st Team | Third Base | |
| Nicole Giordano | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| 2002 | |||
| Jennie Finch | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Leneah Manuma | 1st Team | First Base | |
| 2003 | |||
| Autumn Champion | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Alicia Hollowell | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Lovie Jung | 1st Team | Shortstop | |
| Courtney Fossatti | 2nd Team | Outfield | |
| 2004 | |||
| Wendy Allen | 1st Team | Designated Player | |
| Autumn Champion | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Alicia Hollowell | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Caitlin Lowe | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| 2005 | |||
| Kristie Fox | 1st Team | Shortstop | |
| Caitlin Lowe | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Alicia Hollowell | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| 2006 | |||
| Kristie Fox | 1st Team | Shortstop | |
| Caitlin Lowe | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Alicia Hollowell | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| 2007 | |||
| Caitlin Lowe | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Taryne Mowatt | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| 2008 | |||
| Brittany Lastrapes | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| Laine Roth | 3rd Team | First Base | |
| 2009 | |||
| Brittany Lastrapes | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Stacie Chambers | 3rd Team | Catcher | |
| Jenae Leles | 3rd Team | Third Base | |
| 2010 | |||
| Kenzie Fowler | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Brittany Lastrapes | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| K'Lee Arredondo | 2nd Team | Shortstop | |
| Stacie Chambers | 2nd Team | Catcher | |
| 2011 | |||
| Brittany Lastrapes | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Brigette Del Ponte | 2nd Team | Third Base | |
| Kenzie Fowler | 2nd Team | Pitcher | |
| 2014 | |||
| Hallie Wilson | 1st Team | First Base | |
| Kellie Fox | 3rd Team | Shortstop | |
| 2015 | |||
| Chelsea Goodacre | 2nd Team | Catcher | |
| Kellie Fox | 3rd Team | Shortstop | |
| Katiyana Mauga | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| 2017 | |||
| Jessie Harper | 1st Team | First Base | |
| Danielle O'Toole | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Katiyana Mauga | 2nd Team | Third Base | |
| Mo Mercado | 2nd Team | Shortstop | |
| 2018 | |||
| Alyssa Palomino-Cardoza | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| 2019 | |||
| Taylor McQuillin | 1st Team | Pitcher | |
| Dejah Mulipola | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Alyssa Palomino-Cardoza | 1st Team | Outfield | |
| Reyna Carranco | 2nd Team | Second Base | |
| Jessie Harper | 2nd Team | Shortstop | |
| 2020 | |||
| All-Americans not awarded | |||
| 2021 | |||
| Dejah Mulipola | 1st Team | Catcher | |
| Alyssa Denham | 3rd Team | Pitcher | |
| Jessie Harper | 3rd Team | Shortstop | |
| Janelle Meoño | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| 2022 | |||
| Allie Skaggs | 2nd Team | Second Base | |
| 2024 | |||
| Dakota Kennedy | 3rd Team | Outfield | |
| 2025 | |||
| Devyn Netz | 2nd Team | Utility/Pitcher | |
| Sydney Stewart | 2nd Team | Catcher | |
| Dakota Kennedy | 3rd Team | Outfield |
